Making Education Easy Issue 30 – 2011
Authors: Qato DM et al
Summary: This US-based investigation surveyed racial and ethnic disparities in the use of statins and aspirin among 3005 older community-dwelling adults (aged 57–85 years) at low (n=812), moderate (n=977), and high risk (n=1066) for cardiovascular disease (CVD) between June 2005 and March 2006. The paper reports the highest rates of use among respondents at high cardiovascular risk. Racial differences were highest among respondents at high risk, with Blacks less likely than Whites to use statins (38% vs 50%) and aspirin (29% vs 44%). Racial/ethnic disparities persisted after controlling for confounding factors.
Comment: Importantly, although the authors talk about disparities in ‘participant use of medication’, on closer reading of the paper it appears that the researchers looked at ‘presence of medication’ in the home. This suggests that disparities in ‘adults use’ are in fact due to lower rates in ‘prescriptions’ for African Americans with high CVD risk. The fact that disparities increased with CVD risk is also alarming. Strategies to consider in our own practice may include clinical audits (to monitor prescribing practice) and health literacy interventions that empower patients/whānau.
Reference: Pharmacoepidemiol Drug Saf. 2010;19(8):834-42.
Abstract
www.maorihealthreview.co.nz a Research Review Publication
Authors: Thomas DR et al
Summary: Findings are reported from semi-structured interviews with 23 general practitioners (GPs) in the Auckland region, including both Māori and non-Māori GPs, that elicited their views about risk factors for depression, recognising depression and circumstances in which GPs would prescribe medication or recommend other treatments for depression. The interviewers hoped to establish possible reasons for reported lower levels of diagnosis and treatment of depression among Māori compared to non-Māori patients. Reasons reported by GPs as most likely to lead to ethnic differences in diagnosing depression were greater stigma relating to admitting depression among Māori patients, Māori patients being less likely to talk about being depressed, and the need for patients to have effective communication with their GP. Effective communication, where Māori patients felt free to talk about personal feelings, was more likely when there was an established relationship between the GP and patient.
Comment: This study aims to understand why Māori with depression are less likely to have a correct diagnosis and appropriate management. Increasingly, we are seeing literature that describes the ‘provider’s perspective’ in an attempt to explain ethnic disparities. This paper goes further to consider skills that could be taught to GPs in order to improve their practice.
Reference: J Prim Health Care. 2010;2(3):208-16.
Authors: Hotu C et al
Summary: The efficacy of a novel, integrated, community-based model of care using culturally appropriate health-care assistants to manage hypertension in Māori and Pacific patients with diabetes and chronic kidney disease (CKD) was compared with that of conventional care in achieving blood pressure (BP) targets and delaying progression of cardiac and renal end-organ damage. The study cohort consisted of 65 Māori and Pacific patients (aged 47–75 years) with type 2 diabetes, moderate CKD (>0.5 g proteinuria/day, serum creatinine 130–300 μmol/L) and hypertension, who were randomised to usual care (n=32) or community/ intervention care (n=33) for 12 months. Community care patients were visited monthly by a nurse-led health care assistant for BP measurement. By 12 months, the community care patients had achieved a significantly greater reduction in office systolic BP (−21 mmHg vs −12 mmHg; p=0.04) and in 24h urine protein (−1.4 g vs +0.1 g; p=0.04). The number of prescribed antihypertensives was greater in these patients at 12 months (3.4 vs 2.3; p<0.01). Left ventricular mass and left atrial volume progressed in the usual care group, but not in the intervention group.
Comment: I think key factors in the success of this ‘intervention’ are (1) the Māori and Pacific health worker (referred to as a health care assistant in the paper); (2) the health care assistants working closely with nurse leaders; (3) integrated care across primary and secondary services including communication between providers; (4) the ‘education package’ about hypertension and reasons for medication and; (5) regular contact.
Reference: Nephrol Dial Transplant. 2010;25(10):3260-6.
Privacy Policy: Research Review will record your email details on a secure database and will not release them to anyone without your prior approval. Research Review and you have the right to inspect, update or delete your details at any time. The views expressed in this Publication are personal to the authors, and do not necessarily represent the views or policy of the Ministry of Health on the issues dealt with in the publication.
Disclaimer: This publication is not intended as a replacement for regular medical education but to assist in the process. The reviews are a summarised interpretation of the published study and reflect the opinion of the writer rather than those of the research group or scientific journal. It is suggested readers review the full trial data before forming a final conclusion on its merits.
Research Review publications are intended for New Zealand health professionals.
Authors: Shimony A et al
Summary: These Israeli researchers sought to determine whether the socioeconomic status of a community influences the characteristics and outcome of patients treated with percutaneous coronary intervention (PCI), using data from the Israel Central Bureau of Statistics, which assigns a socioeconomic index (SI) to communities based on demographic, economic and educational parameters. The SI was determined for 1397 patients who underwent PCI between April 2004 and October 2006; patients were divided into low, intermediate or high SI. Compared with an intermediate or high SI, a low SI community socioeconomic level was associated with a significantly younger age, significantly higher rates of diabetes and of smoking, a significantly lower rate of drug-eluting stent implantation, lower adherence to aspirin and clopidogrel therapy, a significantly higher rate of repeat revascularisation and a higher rate of recurrent myocardial infarction. A lower SI was an independent predictor of major adverse cardiac events during follow-up (HR, 1.52).
Comment: PCI may not be appropriate treatment for coronary artery disease in smokers or people with diabetes. In these cases, CABG (coronary artery bypass grafts) should be considered for the microvascular and multi-vessel nature of the disease. Given the poor outcomes associated with PCI in people with low SI, perhaps guidelines should be revised to ensure that a ‘high level of deprivation associated with DM and smoking’ is considered in or contributes to a lower threshold for recommending CABG.
Reference: Int J Cardiol. 2010;144(3):379-82.
Authors: Landes DP et al
Summary: Outcomes are reported from a health equity audit undertaken in County Durham, England, to support the targeting of resources to meet the needs of patients from deprived communities, in areas where levels of poor oral health remain higher than the rest of the population as a whole. The researchers matched postcodes of 224,107 patients in County Durham to Lower Super Output Areas (LSOA) for each practice. Deprivation scores were identified for each LSOA. The postcode of 59 dental practices was matched to the LSOA and the practice population divided into quintiles from the most to the least deprived areas. The more deprived the area in which a dental practice was located, the greater the proportion of the practice population accessing care from the most deprived quintile. The size of the practice alone was not directly related to meeting the needs of a more deprived population.
Comment: This paper supports the notion of an ‘inverse care law’ operating in dental care in North England, whereby dental practices have set up in areas of high demand rather than high need. As the authors suggest, targeted investment to meet local need is required to address dental health inequities; many Māori providers have already established Orange Niho care on site and perhaps Whānau Ora centres should also consider investing into oral health services.
Reference: Br Dent J. 2010;209, E3.
Authors: Sarfati D et al
Summary: This paper discusses the evidence in support of the importance of bowel cancer screening in Māori New Zealanders. Currently, Māori have lower incidence of colorectal cancer compared with NZ Europeans, but the rates are increasing more rapidly among Māori. Moreover, despite this lower incidence, the colorectal cancer mortality burden is similar for Māori and NZ Europeans. Notably, colorectal cancer mortality rates have generally increased since the early 1980s among Māori, yet have remained stable or declined among NZ Europeans. In addition, survival among Māori with colorectal cancer is lower than that for non-Māori. There is evidence of poorer access and quality of care contributing to poorer colorectal cancer survival in Māori compared with non-Māori patients. A pilot bowel cancer screening programme is planned; the authors of this paper stress that attention must be paid to the effectiveness of this programme for Māori as well as European New Zealanders. Its introduction has the potential to reduce ethnic disparities in colorectal cancer survival, if screening is accompanied by investment in diagnostic and treatment services (such as colonoscopy).
Comment: With the roll-out of bowel cancer screening, and potential for further cancer screening programmes to be developed/implemented with advancing technologies, it’s timely to consider the place of such initiatives for Māori. This opinion piece provides a description of the issues that is both comprehensive and relevant so that when faced with a similar question – is this important for Māori – we can respond appropriately.
Reference: N Z Med J. 2010;123(1320):9-12.
Authors: Smith SK et al
Summary: This study was conducted in areas in New South Wales, Australia, identified as socioeconomically disadvantaged (low education attainment, high unemployment, and unskilled occupations), to determine whether a decision aid designed for adults with low education and literacy can support informed choice and involvement in decisions about screening for bowel cancer. The study involved 572 adults (55–64 years) with low educational attainment, eligible for bowel cancer screening. The intervention group received a patient decision aid comprising a paper-based interactive booklet (with and without a question prompt list) and a DVD, presenting quantitative risk information on the possible outcomes of screening using faecal occult blood testing compared with no testing. The control group received standard information developed for the Australian national bowel screening programme. Participants who received the decision aid showed higher levels of knowledge than the controls; mean scores (maximum score 12) were 6.50 for the decision aid group and 4.10 for the control group (p<0.001). Fewer participants in the decision aid group compared with those in the control group expressed favourable attitudes towards screening (51% vs 65%; p=0.002) and the participation rate for screening was reduced in the decision aid group: 59% completed faecal occult blood testing versus 75% in the control group (p=0.001). The decision aid increased the proportion of participants who made an informed choice, from 12% in the control group to 34% in the decision aid group (p<0.001). More participants in the decision aid group had no decisional conflict about the screening decision compared with the controls (51% vs 38%; p=0.02).
Comment: As follow-on to the previous paper, an interesting study on two counts. Firstly, the effectiveness of a decision aid support in improving knowledge about diagnostic testing without raising fear/anxiety. And secondly, that an informed choice (based on all evidence) is not always associated with uptake of screening.
Reference: BMJ. 2010;341:c5370.
Authors: Alexander H et al
Summary: These researchers retrospectively analysed data from 301 patients undergoing surgery for high-grade glioma (HGG) in New Zealand between 1993 and 2003. The study aimed to determine the relationship of ethnicity with incidence, treatment and survival. Agestandardised incidence rates for HGG did not differ between Māori and non-Māori patients (4.2 vs 4.1 per 100,000 person years). Māori were more likely to have complete tumour resection (OR, 3.59) but waited 1.32 times longer for radiotherapy. Median survival was 29 weeks, with poorer survival in Māori compared to non-Māori (HR, 1.55).
Comment: An example of researching the health care pathway – and that it’s not enough to stop at incidence rates when they appear ‘equal’. As the researchers have shown, despite equal rates in occurrence and initial treatment, the disparities in long-term treatment appear to contribute to poo
Reference: J Clin Neurosci. 2010;17(9):1144-7.
Authors: Tipene-Leach D et al
Summary: Outcomes are reported from a survey of Māori mothers who gave birth in the Counties Manukau District Health Board area. This survey investigated what these mothers know about SIDS prevention, and sought to determine their SIDS-related child care practices. Results were compared with a similar 2005 survey of a largely European sample. Knowledge of Māori mothers about SIDS prevention was much lower than for European mothers. More Māori infants slept prone and Māori mothers stopped breastfeeding significantly earlier. Although co-sleeping rates were similar, bedsharing increased to 65% for some part of the night. In addition, more than half of the Māori mothers had smoked in pregnancy and 21% of them were sharing a bed with their infant. Potentially unsafe soft objects such as rolled blankets or pillows were used by a third of mothers to help maintain the sleep position.
Comment: It would be easy to appoint blame with mums (“why can’t you stop smoking, breastfeed longer and stop sleeping with baby?”) but as the authors say, the information should be used to develop appropriate measures. SIDS continues to be a major cause of Māori babies dying; providers must ensure better outcomes for pēpi through the provision of effective education, support and resources.
Reference: N Z Med J. 2010;123(1326):88-96
Authors: McClintock K et al
Summary: Māori value the traditional Pōwhiri process of engagement and participation in mental health; the practices and protocols of this process are founded on the notion of respect and positive relationships between the tangata whenua (hosts or research participants) and manuwhiri (guests or researchers). The paper’s authors suggest that the Pōwhiri process may be a model applicable to research with other indigenous cultures.
Comment: A great example of a Kaupapa Māori methodology being presented in an international forum. The authors have not only described the process so that others may consider utilising it in their research methods, they have also provided an informative critique.
Reference: Int J Soc Psychiatry. 2010 Nov 18. [Epub ahead of print]