ISSN ISSN 1178-6191
Making Education Easy Issue 95– 2022
Nau mai, haere mai ki a Māori Health Review. We aim to bring you top Māori and Indigenous health research from Aotearoa and internationally. Ngā mihi nui ki Manatu Hauora Māori for sponsoring this review, which comes to you every two months. Ko te manu e kai i te miro nōna te ngahere, Ko te manu kai i te mātauranga, nōna te ao.
In our first issue for 2022, we report large-scale evidence that group A streptococcus skin infections increase the risk of acute rheumatic fever, particularly in Māori and Pacific individuals, and that antibiotic dispensing does not reduce this risk. We also feature two studies investigating the importance of culturally appropriate approaches and shared decision-making when engaging Māori in health services. Finally, we include a whole-of-population study which highlights the important role primary care physicians play in recognising and addressing suicide risk. We hope you find this issue informative and of value in your daily practice. We welcome your comments and feedback. Nga mihi Dr Matire Harwood matire@maorihealthreview.co.nz
Authors: Oliver J et al.
Summary: A large study of throat and skin swab data from the Auckland region has demonstrated that group A streptococcus (GAS) skin infections are strongly associated with subsequent acute rheumatic fever. A total of 1,866,981 throat and skin swabs collected between 2010 and 2017 were analysed, as well as antibiotic dispensing data for the same period and hospitalisations for acute rheumatic fever between 2010 and 2018. Māori and Pacific individuals had the highest risk of acute rheumatic fever in the 8- to 90-day period following a GAS-positive throat (relative risk 4.8; 95% CI 3.6-6.4) or skin (relative risk 5.1; 95% CI 1.8-15.0) swab. Antibiotic dispensing was not associated with a reduction in the risk of acute rheumatic fever following either a GAS-positive throat or skin swab.
Comment: Although some have hypothesised that GAS skin infections are associated with subsequent acute rheumatic fever, this study provides clear evidence for it, including its risk compared with traditional throat infections, and the increased risk for Māori and Pacific peoples.
Reference: BMJ Glob Health. 2021;6(12):e007038.
Abstract
www.maorihealthreview.co.nz a Research Review Publication
Authors: Edmonds LK et al.
Summary: European women are significantly less likely to give birth to extremely or very preterm infants compared with Māori women, and their infants are at lower risk of early neonatal or post-neonatal death, according to a Kaupapa Māori research study. The study analysed maternity, mortality and hospital data for women and their infants born in New Zealand between 1 January 2010 and 31 December 2014. The adjusted relative risk of having an extremely or very preterm infant was 0.86 (95% CI 0.76-0.95) for European women compared with Māori women. Corresponding adjusted relative risks of early neonatal death and post-neonatal death were 0.65 (95% CI 0.45-0.93) and 0.41 (95% CI 0.26-0.64), respectively. In addition to ethnicity, the risk of preterm birth was also influenced by maternal age, body mass index, smoking status and small for gestational age status. The study authors concluded that the New Zealand maternity system privileges whiteness, and that evidence-based medical care is not delivered systemically and equitably for all.
Comment: Another important paper from this excellent team. Interesting that they have chosen to focus on New Zealand European rates, demonstrating inequities by focussing on how an ethnic group is privileged. I’m still in two minds about this approach as I’m not sure that it will drive the necessary changes in our system. Interested to hear others’ thoughts.
Reference: Int J Gynaecol Obstet. 2021;155(2): 239-246.
Privacy Policy: Research Review will record your email details on a secure database and will not release them to anyone without your prior approval. Research Review and you have the right to inspect, update or delete your details at any time. The views expressed in this Publication are personal to the authors, and do not necessarily represent the views or policy of the Ministry of Health on the issues dealt with in the publication.
Disclaimer: This publication is not intended as a replacement for regular medical education but to assist in the process. The reviews are a summarised interpretation of the published study and reflect the opinion of the writer rather than those of the research group or scientific journal. It is suggested readers review the full trial data before forming a final conclusion on its merits.
Research Review publications are intended for New Zealand health professionals.
Authors: Lawrenson R et al.
Summary: In a study of Waikato DHB data, the likelihood of colorectal cancer in patients undergoing colonoscopy following GP referral with a high suspicion of cancer (HSCan) was almost 15%. The study authors suggested that such patients should be routinely prioritised without further triage by the hospital. They assessed e-referral data for patients aged at least 30 years referred from 75 general practices to general surgery, gastroenterology or direct to colonoscopy between 1 January 2015 and 31 December 2017. A total of 6718/20648 (32.5%) patients underwent colonoscopy, of whom 372 (5.5%) were diagnosed with colorectal cancer. Females, non-Māori, and patients with a HSCan label originating from their GP were more likely to have a colonoscopy. Among the 585 patients with a GP HSCan label who underwent colonoscopy, the odds ratio of a colorectal cancer diagnosis 2.34 (95% CI 1.70-3.22). However, 423 of these patients were reprioritised by the hospital and 55 had their diagnosis unnecessarily delayed.
Comment: Given our recent lockdowns, and now long waiting lists for investigations, I agree with the recommendation to prioritise GP referred patients without further hospital triaging. And given the significant disparities in colon cancer survival between Māori and non-Māori, an equity approach must also be prioritised.
Reference: BMC Gastroenterol. 2021;21(1):471.
Authors: Lippmann J et al.
Summary: Māori appear to be over-represented in New Zealand scuba diving-related fatalities, according to a study of data from 2007 to 2016. Data were obtained from the National Coronial Information System, the New Zealand Chief Coroner’s office, Water Safety New Zealand Drownbase™ and the New Zealand Police National Dive Squad records. A total of 48 fatalities were identified, including 40 men and 8 women, of whom 20 were Māori. Average age was 47 years, and 35 individuals were classified as overweight or obese. Identified medical risk factors included ischaemic heart disease (20 individuals), left ventricular hypertrophy (18) and hypertension (7). Multiple environmental and diving practice breaches, and poor planning, were identified in a chain of events analysis. Thirty-eight individuals had not released their weight belt, and information on resuscitation was limited.
Comment: Reporting numbers, especially when we see inequities, is important. However, the narrative or way we speak to those numbers is just as critical. Here, I felt that the results were reported in ways that could be considered ‘victim-blaming’ with not enough attention to system factors, or solutions.
Reference: Diving Hyperb Med. 2021;51(4):345- 354.
Authors: Chiang A et al.
Summary: A New Zealand whole-of-population study has determined that contact with a health service in the 6 months prior to death is associated with increased odds of suicide. The study examined all individuals aged at least 15 years who were alive on 5 March 2013, with follow-up to December 2015. Of the suicide decedent population, 59.4% had contacted primary health services, 46.5% had contacted secondary health services, and 30.4% had contacted tertiary health services in the 6 months prior to death. Contact with primary, secondary and tertiary services was associated with odds ratios for suicide of 2.51 (95% CI 2.19-2.88), 4.45 (95% CI 3.69-4.66) and 6.57 (95% CI 5.84-7.38), respectively, compared with those who had no health services contact.
Comment: Two important points stood out for me here. First, the overall findings about previous contact with health services. As a GP, although the odds were lowest for people accessing primary care, general practices are also the most frequently contacted. Therefore, primary care plays an important role and better support for primary care clinicians to recognise and address suicide risk is key. Second, the excellent reporting on Māori data – what’s missing and why. Readers should take a look at the Discussion.
Reference: PLoS One. 2021;16(12):e0261163.
Authors: Wilson D et al.
Summary: The importance and relevance of relational approaches to engaging Māori and their whānau accessing health services has been highlighted in a qualitative literature review. Health and wellbeing for Māori is a holistic and relational concept, and building relationships that include whānau is a cultural imperative. Key elements for a Māori-centred model of relational care include whakawhanaungatanga (the process of building relationships) using tikanga (cultural protocols and processes) and informed by cultural values of aroha (compassion and empathy), manaakitanga (kindness and hospitality), mauri (binding energy), and wairua (importance of spiritual wellbeing).
Comment: Tā Mason himself would argue that we should continue to build, revise and grow models of hauora Māori. For me, the elements aligned with Kaupapa Māori Theory (particularly Linda Smith’s Decolonising Methodologies) and Vision Matauranga and Charles Royal’s idea that such models can revitalise our cultural ways of knowing, as well as achieve social justice, in ways that generate new knowledge.
Reference: J Clin Nurs. 2021;30(23-24):3539-3555.
Authors: Gifford H et al.
Summary: A qualitative study informed by Kaupapa Māori theory has demonstrated that although Māori are concerned about the rising cost of tobacco, this has generally not translated into quit attempts. The study involved interviews with 72 Māori individuals, most of whom were smokers, from 15 whānau units in two geographical regions - one rural/provincial and one urban. The study showed that whānau have developed innovative tobacco-related practices to continue smoking, albeit in a modified fashion, despite the rising costs of tobacco. The study authors concluded that hypothecated taxes should be used to scale up Māori-specific cessation and uptake prevention programmes, including restricting the availability and appeal of tobacco.
Comment: Great to see attention being given to this important kaupapa. Lockdowns may have also impacted on access to tobacco and therefore smoking?
Reference: Tob Control. 2021;30(e2):e144-e149.
Authors: Anderson R et al.
Summary: Although rates of surgery for urinary incontinence and pelvic floor prolapse were similar between Māori and non-Māori in a New Zealand study, the greater prevalence of these conditions in Māori women means this likely represents inequity of access. The study reviewed women who underwent gynaecological surgery between 2015 and 2019 in the Southern DHB area. Unadjusted results suggested that there was a difference in access to gynaecological surgery for Māori and non-Māori. However, standardisation for differences in the age structures of the two populations showed that Māori and non-Māori women access this surgery at very similar rates.
Comment: There is some interesting work coming from Southern DHB – the strong Iwi Māori leadership there may be driving the focus on research that is responsive to Māori. I’ve included this paper as a good reminder on how to report that equal process does not necessarily translate as equity.
Reference: N Z Med J. 2021;134(1546):38-46.
Authors: Houkamau C et al.
Summary: A large New Zealand study has highlighted the prevalence of cyberbullying in Māori adults. Individuals aged 18-83 years (n = 6,529) who completed the questionnaire-based Māori Identity and Financial Attitudes Study in 2017 were included in the present study. On average, 19.3% of participants reported ever experiencing cyberbullying, and 4.1% reported experiencing cyberbullying within the past month. When analysed by age group, young adults (aged 18-25 years) experienced the highest rates of cyberbullying. Rates of cyberbullying were also higher among women and those identifying as a minority sexual orientation compared with men and heterosexuals. Individuals who identified as Māori as one of their multiple ethnicities experienced higher rates of cyberbullying than those who identified as Māori only. The study discusses practical and theoretical implications in light of Māori mental health outcomes.
Comment: This research is close to my heart, as my 10-year-old experienced online bullying from ‘friends’ last year. Our young people will become increasingly exposed to cyberbullying with online learning and reduced opportunities for social interactions. Thankfully the school was incredible in its response, but we’ve had to take action as a whānau too. There are some great practical tips outlined in this paper.
Reference: Cyberpsychol Behav Soc Netw. 2021;24(12):822-830.
Authors: Tipene-Leach D et al.
Summary: Choosing Wisely is an international health quality improvement campaign designed to prevent harm by reducing the number of unnecessary tests, treatments and procedures, and by promoting shared decision-making. In this study, 8 Māori consumers and 7 Māori health practitioners were interviewed about the Choosing Wisely New Zealand campaign and its messages. Study participants highlighted issues ranging from lack of Māori participation in programme governance through to practical issues like meaningful and literacyappropriate health messaging, traversing consumer, practitioner, organisational and health-system aspects. Participant feedback also indicated the need for patients to have trust in the practitioner, a sense of autonomy and availability of advocacy and support in the consultation. The study authors noted that Choosing Wisely New Zealand is the first of the international programmes to acknowledge the possibility that their initiative might increase inequity for indigenous populations. They stressed the need to consult Māori early and to infuse Treaty principles and Māori knowledge and custom at every stage of the programme.
Comment: A key message here – it’s never too late to bring the Treaty principles into your project. As a reminder these are Partnership, Equity, Active protection, Tino Rangatiratanga and Options. Kia kaha koutou!
Reference: N Z Med J. 2021;134(1547):26-33.